2006 Musigny, Domaine Joseph Drouhin

Quite deep intensity ruby coloured with pronounced noses of rose garden, red plum, ripe strawberry, forest floor and spice box, quite complex. It is dry with medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with medium fine grained tannin. On palate it has fairly intense flavours of red cherry, red tea, wild strawberry, rose pedal and licorice spice. Fairly long length with red cherry finish. (93) Smooth and great nose.
 

Tasted on 21 November 2024 

酒香出色，係非常之出色，強而複雜，有深度，像在說故事似的。酒的強度一直延至口中，口感柔順餘韻算長，好喝，酒味由濃烈方向轉向陰柔，有一點變化，好酒一支，絕對係適合慢慢品嚐的美酒

2017 Chambolle Musigny Les Charmes 1er Cru, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

Deep intensity ruby colour with quite intense noses of rose, dried strawberries, candied redcurrant, cabbage and licorice, it is dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied. The tannin is soft at medium level, surprisingly ripe. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red plum, strawberry, rose pedal, licorice and touch of forest floor. Longer than medium length with red plum finish. (91) Good intensity and nose, some typicity as well.

 

Tasted on 4 October 2024

酒的力度算強勁，香氣亦很好，只是以這條村來說是重了一點。酒的口味反而更符合這條村的感覺，但強度不及香氣，餘韻亦合格以上，難得的是這支酒的丹寧出奇的成熟柔順，不像2017年的酒，整體來說是一支好喝的酒品

2009 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Amoureuses, Domaine Bertheau

This is a dry red burgundy with quite deep intensity ruby colour. On nose it has pronounced intensity aromas of red berry, wild strawberry, forest floor, wet earth, pine, mushroom, rose pedal and touch of plum, very floral. Medium acidity and alcohol, medium bodied with soft and ripe medium tannin. The flavour intensity is over medium level with flavours of red cherry, tea, strawberry, green plum, rose and touch of vegetal. Fairly long length with red cherry finish. (93) A nice Chambolle, very floral and wild fruit, soft and elegant. 

 

Tasted on 24 April 2024

相信很多人如果在盲飲的話也喝得出這是 Chambolle 的酒。這酒的味道結構傾向花香及野生果實，亦有田土特色，個性突出，酒的強度中上，複雜性亦然。餘𩐳亦長，是一支很好喝的愛侶田，希望多點人做這一類風格的，不要次次都把酒味弄至醬果的感覺⋯⋯

2016 Chambolle Musigny Domaine Philippe Pacalet

This dry red wine still has deep intensity ruby colour. On nose it has close to pronounced level aromas of rose, strawberry, cinnnamon, clove and trace of wormwood, pretty spicy. The acidity is a bit over medium level and mouthwatering in nature. Medium alcohol and bodied with medium fine grained tannin. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of red cherry, strawberry, tea leaf, licorice, much greener mouthfeel. The length is medium  with a red cherry finish. (90) Flavours turn green and gone fast.

 

Tasted on 12 April 2023

 

這支酒的香料味道出奇的複雜，有點令到他不像這條村的作品，酸度仍算強，但酒的香氣和酒味強度也很強，但是酒味在口中的感覺，不像香氣那種濃烈成熟，反而轉為較清爽明澈，餘韻亦比想像中短，幾好喝。我感覺酒莊好像想做一款很濃烈的葡萄酒，在香氣是很成功的，但在酒味及口中轉化方便，似乎仍需要努力。
 

2019 Chambolle Musigny, Domaine Coquard Loison Fleurot

A deep ruby coloured Chambolle with medium intensity noses of rose, strawberry, cedar, vanilla, wild red cherry, pretty attractive. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and bodied with ripe and soft medium tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red plum, red cherry, rose and licorice. Longer than medium length with red plummy finish. (90) Good floral and fruit notes, show good vintage.

 

Tasted on 26 March 2023

年份好帶來的恩賜。酒的強度雖然不是很犀利，但足夠把酒中的花果香味完全綻放出來。香氣很吸引亦很誘人。各方面都合格，雖然不是一支很複雜的酒品，但清晰純淨的好喝。

2013 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Charmes, Domaine Laurent Roumier

Deep ruby colour with quite intense noses of rose pedal, red berry, plum, strawberry, cedar and trace of anise and smoke. It is dry with medium acidity and alcohol, medium bodied with medium soft tannin. On palate it gives medium intensity flavours of cherrry, plum, rose pedal, wild strawberry and vanilla spice. Longer than medium length with cherry finish. (91)

 

Tasted on 1 January 2022

輕巧陰柔，香氣強但給人一種陰柔感，很好的風格表現。香料及果味的平衡好。以這年份來說單寧也很不錯。酒味在口中不及香氣那麼吸引，餘韻亦合格有餘，幾好喝，很有園野風味的酒。

2012 Bonnes Mares, Domaine Philippe Pacalet

This dry red wine has deep ruby colour. On nose it has pronounced aromas of red cherry, red plum, strawberry jam, cabbage and trace of anise, fresh and spicy. Medium acidity, a bit sharp tho. The alcohol is at medium level and full bodied. Smooth medium tannin as well. The flavour intensity is quite high with flavours of red cherry, plum, strawberry, licorice, cabbage and anise. Fairly long length with red cherry finish. (93)
 

Tasted on 7 August 2021

也是有著一貫的醬果感，酒仍是很年青，但香料味已開始發揮出來，特別是在口中的時候。酒力強，複雜性仍需時間展現，餘韻亦長，好酒一枝。酒的香料味在口中發展似乎比香氣快，相信過幾年應該會開始要密切注意適飲期。

2010 Chambolle Musigny, Domaine Comte Georges de Vouge

Deep ruby colour with medium nose of red cherry, raspberry jam, rose, mint, floral field, vanilla and licorice. It is dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied with quite high ripe and soft tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red cherry, raspberry, rose, mushroom and tea. Fairly long length with red cherry finish. (91) Shows some elegance with decent flavour profile.


Tasted on 24 February 2019

三支中這枝的風格最像樣，在口中的表現亦是最好，雖然香氣方面不及09年的，但酒的香氣一點也不差，只是強度有點不足。餘韻不錯，待一些時候單寧再低一點會更好，給它一點時間吧......

2009 Chambolle Musigny, Domaine Comte Georges de Vouge

A deep ruby coloured dry red wine with over medium intensity aromas of meat, black plum, blood, red cherry, dried rose, earth and smoke. Medium acidity, alcohol and bodied with medium soft tannin. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of red plum, rose, strawberry juice, licorice and vegetal. Medium length with red cherry finish. (90) A bit heavy, ripe and rich flavour but a bit weak in mid palate.


Tasted on 24 February 2019

比08年的多一些複雜性，味道層次亦多一點，強度亦強一點。亦貫徹著較厚重的風格。酒的香氣比口中表現好一些，酒在口中有一點點空洞，餘韻亦算好。濃厚的餐酒。

2008 Chambolle Musigny, Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue

Deep ruby colour with rose attack, then medium nose of black plum, mint, strawberry jam, licorice and trace of smoke. Dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied. Medium ripe and fine grain tannin with medium length and red cherry finish. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of red cherry, strawberry, tea, mushroom and licorice. (90) Ripe fruit and straight forward


Tasted on 24 February 2019

直飲三步曲第一枝，果味足，簡單直接的濃厚果感，撲鼻而至。酒在口聿表現中規中矩，有一定發展而又不失果味，幾好飲。但個人覺得這村酒造得略為厚重，欠點優雅。

2008 Musigny, Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue

Deep ruby coloured dry red wine with close to pronounced level of armoas, strawberry jam, black plum, rose, sandalwood, pine, trace of red flower garden. Nice floral notes. Medium acidity, alcohol and bodied. Fine grained medium tannin too. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of black cherry, red plum, red tea, licorice, rose and touch of mushroom. Fairly long length wtih black cherry finish. (93) Jammy nose with lighter palate, some depth too.


Tasted on 2 November 2018

花香味很吸引，酒香與酒味表現不同。酒香的果味較醬果，酒味的較清新，酒的味道有一定層次，頗有深度。口感仍是有點重，還可陳年一段時間，現在喝不出這葡萄園如絲般的酒質。

2001 Bonnes Mares, Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue

Medium intensity ruby colur with quite intense aromas of rose, strawberry, wild cherry, red berry, sandalwood and touch of earth, meat at the back. Good layer. Dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied with medium tannin, a bit stalky tho. Quite intense flavours of red berry, cherry, rose tea and vegetal. Fairly long length with red cherry finish. (92) Good berry fruit.

Tasted on 16 June 2018

酒香很有層次，清晰分明，香氣出眾。酒入口後差了點 ，雖然酒力仍然強，但複雜性下降了，餘韻長，莓纇果味充足，好喝的。這莊的酒也是重炮手一個，酒力十分澎湃，所以要酒味爆的人會很喜歡。

1999 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Amoureuses, Domaine Robert Groffier

Deep ruby coloured with close to pronounced level aromas of black plum, meat, smoke, earth, sandalwood, anise and rose. Medium acidit, alcohol and bodied. Quite high ripe and fine grained tannin with quite high flavours of black plum, blood, rose, smoke, earth and touch of rain forest. Long length with plum and spicy finish. (92) Good after taste but a bit meaty.


Tasted on 9 February 2018

老實說這葡萄園的酒我較喜輕柔感多一些的。這酒較厚重，但不是說它不好。酒的強度香氣酒味複雜性也在中上之列，單寧成熟柔順，餘韻更值得一讚，酒的質量來說十分高。只是欠缺了些這村那陰柔的感覺，取而代之的是厚實較MEATY的風格。好好酒來的。

1999 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Amoureuses, Domaine Robert Groffier

Deep ruby with quite pronounced noses of black plum, rose, earth, toasted herbs, mushroom, and touch of sandalwood, cedar, it is dry with medium acidity, alcohol and quite full bodied. Medium fine grain tannin with over medium intensity flavours of red plum, rose, licorice, pine, earth and mushroom. Longer than medium length with red plum finish. (93) bit earthy on nose but good palate.


Tasted on 29 December 2017


99年這條村的酒幾難明，酒的香氣和酒味都有一定的強度和複雜性，餘韻亦算長，中上的酒品。田土特色,不太明顯，亦欠了點點陰柔的感覺。酒好飲，但以這葡萄園來說似乎重口味了些。

2009 Bonnes Mares, Domaine G. Roumier

Deep ruby coloured with quite high noses of mushroom, redberry, cabbage, rose pedal, mint tea and touch of earth, quite elegant with depth. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and quite full bodied. The tannin is soft and fine grained at medium level. On palate it has intense flavours of red plum, cabbage, mushroom, licorice, rose pedal and earth. Long length with red plum finish. (95)


Tasted on 27 October 2017

優雅及濃郁這兩個詞很難放在一起去形容同一枝酒，但當這同時出現時，那一定是一枝好酒了。這酒的酒香強，而複雜性是一層層的走出來，口感柔順而酒味強，味道的方向比香氣的重了些，餘韻長長，令人回味，有種由淺入深的感覺，會令人有想像空間的，好酒。

2005 Chambolle-Musigny Les Clos de l'Orme, Domaine Sylvain Cathiard

Deep ruby with quite pronounced aromas of black plum jam, black berry, rose, vanilla, toast and licorice. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and quite full bodied. Soft and ripe medium tannin as well, with over medium level flavours of black cherry, plum, rose, vanilla and licorice. Fairly long length with black cherry finish. (90)


Tasted on 16 September 2017

果感豐富的酒。每方面表現也在中上的水平，但真的只是中上，即是說如果60分合格的話，它便樣樣70分，別期望80分。酒的口感很好，05年酒的單寧真的很軟熟，令人飲得很舒服的。餘韻亦令人回味，好味，只是複雜性少了點，但村酒來說是很好的。

2003 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Amoureuses, Domaine Robert Groffier

Deep ruby coloured with close to pronounced level aromas of dried red plum, candied redberry, rose jam touch of vanilla and earth, it is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and fuller than medium bodied. Tannin is soft and ripe at medium level, together with a fairly long length. On palate it has over medium intensity flavour of red plum, tea leaves and rose pedal. (93). Maybe storage problem, weirdly a bit dull.



Tasted on 23 June 2017

 這酒有點奇。聞時會感受到此酒厚重濃郁的果感，但就是只有果感加一點點香草味。酒在口中的鮮活性有點不足，即使是03年的也不應這樣。餘韻長，只是複雜性簡單了，以這葡萄園的酒不應如此的。希望是儲存問題吧。

2006 Chambolle Musigny, Domaine Comte Georges de Vouge

A deep ruby dry red wine with pronounced noses of rose perfume, black plum, blackberry, licorice, cedar, earth and touch of cabbage. Medium acidity, alcohol and quite full bodied. The tannin is at medium level and fine grained. On palate it gives higher than medium intensity flavours of red cherry, red plum, earth, licorice and touch of dust. Fairly long length with red plum finish. (92) Just because of nose.


Tasted on 26 January 2017

 酒的香氣很好，又強又複雜，但香氣是偏向濃香的。酒體豐滿的，單寧不算太順滑，但不至於鞋口。酒味力度及複雜性有些下降，餘韻算長，是一枝造得很濃郁的酒，但不太反映到田土特色。因為酒香我加了點分，但整體來說仍是一枝很不錯的酒品。

2000 Bonnes Mares, Domaine Comte Georges de Vouge

This dry red wine has quite deep ruby colour. On nose it has quite high intensity aromas of rose jam, earth, meat, dried red plum, smoke, licorice and touch of raspberry, quite jammy. It has medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied and medium level fine grained tannin. The flavours intensity is over medium level with flavours of rose, redberry, red plum, wild strawberry and touch of licorice, dust and earth. Fairly long length with red plum finish. (93)


Tasted on 10 September 2016

 酒香十分好，強亦複雜，以田土味帶著花果味，而且果感有點醬果的。口感豐厚，餘韻亦算長。酒在口中的味道組合剛剛相反，口中果味充足，而且是由果味主導，有點驚喜，好飲。

2010 Chambolle Musigny 1er Cru Les Hauts Doix, Domaine & Selection (Laurent Ponsot)

Quite deep ruby coloured with over medium intensity aromas of red plum, cherry jam, forest floor, cabbage, mushroom, rose and touch of charcoal. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and fuller than medium bodied. The tannin is soft and ripe at medium level. On palate, it gives slightly higher than medium intensity flavours of red plum, rose jam, redberry, forest floor, cabbage and touch of meat. Fairly long length with red plum finish. (92)

Tasted on 9 July 2016

以這村來說，這酒偏向濃厚，酒的單寧很滑，香氣強度及複雜性也不弱，亦有一定田地特色，餘韻亦長，好飲。酒還可有一些發展，但現飲已經好好味。