2016 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Les Malconsorts, Domaine Francois Lamarche

Deep ruby coloured with pronounced noses of rose, red plum,  strawberry jam, dried red berry, smoke and trace of sweet spices, it is dry with medium acidity and alcohol, full bodied with medium soft and ripe tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red berry, cherr jam, rose garden and trace of mushroom and British tea. Longer than medium length with red berry finish. (92) good nose, a bit lighter on palate, round and smooth

 

Tasted on 1 November 2025

依然的強烈複雜，酒的口感比上次柔順了點。酒亦有一點發展。依舊好喝。但酒味在口中發展似乎快了點，影響了一點陳年能力的判斷。現在喝很不錯，多放兩三年也可⋯⋯

2013 Vosne-Romanee 1er Aux Reignots, Domaine du Comte Liger-Belair

This wine has deep intensity ruby colour. On nose it has medium intensity aromas of rose perfume, red strawberry, red berry, licorice, forest floor and touch of anise. Medium acidity, alcohol and bodied with soft medium tannin, a bit stalky is noted. On palate, it has medium intensity flavours of rose, strawberry jam, licorice, damped wood and red plum. Slightly longer than medium length with rose pedal finish. (91) Very aromatic but a bit weak on palate

 

Tasted on 26 September 2025 

高度複雜，像一本厚厚的書，不過有啲似舊書。酒的強度不算突出，但美好的複雜性蓋過一切，餘韻合格有餘，幾好喝，慢慢嗒一流。

2009 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Aux Brulees, Domaine Meo-Camuzet

This dry wine has quite intense ruby colour. On nose it has medium intensity aromas of rose, red berry, mushroom, mint leaf, flower garden and anise. Pretty complex. Medium acidity and alcohol, full bodied with medium sweet and ripe tannin. The flavour intensity is at medium plus level with flavours of red berry, plum, black tea, licorice, and rose pedal. Fairly long length with red berry finish. (93) Fruity with elegance spicy notes. Nice one.

Tasted on 8 September 2025

好喝。香氣不像很多佳釀的澎湃，是沉穩複雜，口感柔順，味道豐富，餘韻悠長，果味及香料並駕齊驅，現在喝已經很好，當然仍可陳年⋯⋯正

2019 Vosne Romanee Cuvee Quatrain, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

A deep ruby coloured dry red Burgundy with medium intensity aromas of black plum, earth, mushroom, rose jam, smoke and cabbage. Medium acidity and alcohol, full bodied with medium soft and ripe tannin. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of black berry jam, rose perfume, sweet vanilla and cedar. Longer than medium length with black cherry jam finish. (91) Ripe, concentrated and full.

  

Tasted on 3 August 2025 

質素高，不過其實口味幾重。強度很好，餘韻以村酒水平來說是出色的。酒味濃郁、單寧成熟，可以作長期一點的陳年，現在喝要透氣很久，但係有回報的。

2017 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Aux Brulees, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

Deep ruby colour with close to pronounced level aromas of rose perfume, red plum, cabbage, dried strawberry and trace of meat and berry fruits. It is dry with medium acidity and alcohol, medium bodied with soft medium tannin, a touch of greenness is detected. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red cherry, plum, rose tea and licorice. Fairly long length with cherry fruit finish. (92) Good nose but need better palate.
 

Tasted on 11 November 2024 

也許是年份問題吧，酒的單寧有點青。不過香氣很好，強烈濃厚，亦很複雜。餘韻亦長，只是酒在口中的味道不及香氣那樣出色。整體來說表現不錯，相信在一個好些的年份，這酒會有上佳表現。似乎我又要出去搵下⋯⋯

2014 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Gaudichots, Domaine Forey Pere & Fils

A deep ruby dry red burgundy with pronounced noses of rose perfume, red plum, dried strawberry, anise, cedar and touch of dust. Medium acidity, alcohol and bodied with medium fine grained tannin, a bit stalky. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red cherry, British tea, vegtal, black currant leaves and touch of cabbage. Longer than medium length with cherry tea type finish. (910 Good complexity but fading quick in palate, need better length too.
 

Tasted on 23 October 2024 

 

第一下印象係複雜性好，但係酒在口中的強度不足。年份可能亦有影響，單寧有些枝梗味。酒的香氣比酒味出色，餘韻合格有餘，不錯，但相信有進步空間，看看好年的如何，才可更準確評估酒莊功力。

 

2018 Vosne Romanee Aux Champs Perdrix, Domaine Audiffred

This dry red wine has quite intense ruby colour. On nose it has close to pronounced intensity aromas of strawberry, red plum, mint, red cherry, cedar and touch of cabbage and mushroom. Medium acidity and alcohol, medium bodied with medium soft and fine grained tannin. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of red plum, dried cherry, licorice, tea and dark earth. Longer than medium length with red plum finish. (90) A bit weighty tho good complexity

 

Tasted on 2 February 2024

酒香強勁，而且複雜度很高，值得一讚。這個強度去到口中時減弱了一點，但仍算強，複雜性也低了一點，但也不錯。餘韻合格有餘，是一支不錯的酒品，不過似乎在提取方面多了一點，有點重口，甚至有點過咗。

2013 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Les Reignots, Domaine Audiffred

A deep ruby wine with quite intense noses of rose perfume, black plum, forest floor, cedar and touch of mint leaf. Dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and bodied with medium tannin, a touch of greenness though. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of rose, wild red cherry, red plum and forest floor. Longer than medium length with red plum finish. (92) Should be a wonderful wine in good vintage.

 

Tasted on 26 March 2023

試過這酒莊的很多產品，但這支是會令人回味的。酒的複雜性很好，香氣很強勁，酒味在口中轉為清純了，餘韻合格有餘，可能是年份的關係，單寧有一點點的青澀，相信在好年份的話這會是一支很精彩的作品

2019 Vosne Romanee, Domaine Coquard Loison Fleurot

An intense ruby coloured dry red wine with medium noses of black plum, rose jam, earth, licorice and touch of pepper. Medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with soft and ripe medium tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of black plum, rose, black cherry, and touch of damp earth and oak. Long than medium length with plummy finish. (91) Decent.
 

Tasted on 26 March 2023

也是年份令這酒表現出一定的水準。香氣力度不強，但很複雜，丹寧柔順，餘韻亦算合格。是一支中上表演的水準之作。很工整。相信盲飲的情況下很多人也會猜到這支酒的來源地。

2018 Vosne Romanee, Domaine Robert Sirugue

A deep ruby coloured dry red wine with pronounced noses of black plum, earth, meat, menthol, rose jam and anise, pretty heavy and spicy. Medium acidity and alcohol. Full bodied with medium fine grained and ripe tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity black plum, rose jam and licorice. Longer than medium length with black plum finish. (90) Quite heavy profile.

Tasted on 24 February 2023

香氣頗重，酒很緊，似乎要多一點時間。酒氣及味傾向於醬果，香料味出眾，不過入口後弱了點，餘韻以村酒來說合格，酒在口中表現不及香氣，中上的作品，不過少了點柔和感。

2016 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Les Malconsorts, Domaine Francois Lamarche

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense aromas of red cherry, wild strawberry, red plum, rose perfume, anise, vanilla spice and trace of cinnamon. Good fruit and spiciness. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and bodied with medium soft tannin. On palate it gives quite intense flavours of red cherry, strawberry, rose tea and licorice. Close to long length with red cherry finish. (93) Good balance of fruitiness and spiciness. Smooth when drinking at this youth.  

Tasted on 29 August 2022

這酒莊2010年左右轉人之後造得好咗，而且D酒仲似乎可以早飲D，這酒有著高水平的質量，估唔到的是只是有年已很啱飲。酒的果香及香料味均衡，只是在口中的複雜性不及香氣。酒的柔滑度也是有點驚喜的，好喝。

2018 Vosne Romanee, Domaine Audiffred

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense red cherry, dried rose, pine wood and earth, quite floral. It is dry with medium acidity, medium alcohol and bodied, the tannin is soft and fine grained at medium level. Over medium intensity flavours of red plum, dried cherry, earth, licorice and touch of toasted spice. Medium length with cherry finish. (90) Good food wine.

 

Tasted on 1 August 2022

出色的花香，可口柔順，直接地表現出一枝花果味主導的餐酒，再加上一定的複雜性和香料味，喝得很舒暢。四四正正。不錯。

2019 Vosne Romanee Cuvee Quatrain, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

Deep ruby coloured and intense noses of black plum, rose, mint leaf, mushroom, earth and trace of strawberry candy, meat and dried citrus peel, pretty rich nose. It has medium acidity, alcohol and bodied, soft and ripe tannin at medium level too. The flavour intensity is quite high with flavours of black plum, smoke, rose perfume and breakfast tea. Fairly long length with black cherry finish. (93)

Tasted on 13 June 2022

 

香氣複雜強勁，酒體工整，酒味在口中融和，餘韻亦長，這些全是好酒的表現。酒仍有一定的發長空間，但現在喝已經很不錯，比起上星期那一款同莊產品可以早點喝，酒味很集中，有一點穿透力似的，很誘人的酒品。

2019 Vosne Romanee Aux Vigneux, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

A deep ruby coloured dry red wine with quite intense noses of dried black cherry, prune, mint and trace of pine, earth and rose perfume. It has medium acidity, alcohol and full bodied. The tannin is soft at medium level. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of black cherry, plum, rose pedal, strawberry and mushroom. Fairly long length with plummy finish. (93) Concentrated but needs time to develop.

Tasted on 13 June 2022

一枝尚待時間發展的村酒。濃度頗高，有一定複雜性，但相信仍有發揮空間的。單寧柔和，這個年份的酒好像很不錯，酒的香氣有點緊，現飲的話相信要透氣一段很長的時間。酒質很好，陳年一下會有更好的表現。

2016 Vosne Romanee, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

This dry red wine has deep intensity ruby colour. On nose it has quite intense aromas of black plum, earth, smoke, mushroom, dried rose and anise. Very clean and clear nose. Medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with medium fine grained tannin. On palate it has over medium intensity flavours of black plum, rose, vegetal, strawberry tea. Fairly long length with black plum finish. (92) Quite backward but rich.

 

Tasted 13 June 2022

以村酒來說這酒的濃郁度算高。酒力強而有一定複雜性，餘韻也印證了這酒的集中度。酒的味度很分明，條理清晰，結構比較結實，可能是年份關係吧。好喝，仍可陳年，現飲亦已經很可口。

2016 Vosne Romanee 1er Cru La Croix Rameau, Domaine J. Cacheux

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense noses of red plum, rose, earth, mushroom, anise and touch of menthol and sandalwood spice, it has medium acidity, alcohol and quite full bodied. Medium fine grained tannin too. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of rose, cherry, mushroom, vegetal and touch of pine wood. Longer than medium length with red cherry finish. (92) Elegant but seems a bit over extracted.

 

Tasted on 13 June 2022

好VR的一枝酒。香氣吸引，比入口好，結構有點硬硬的。酒的強度及複雜性合格有餘，亦有一定的餘韻。幾好喝，只是收尾感覺到有很輕微的苦澀，扣了些分。

2018 Vosne-Romanee Cuvee Precolombiere, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense noses of dried rose, cherry, plum, strawberry jam, pine and touch of earth. Dry with medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with medium fine grained tannin. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of rose pedal, plum, vanilla and licorice. Medium length with plummy finish. (91) bit coarse mouthfeel.

 

Tasted on 22 April 2022

村酒的香氣強度反而不及它的播干，但不代表其表現失色。強度弱了，但複雜性提高了，果感仍保存得很好，條理仍然分明，現在飲單寧有點點拗口，相信時間會令它馴化，現在飲要多一點時間透氣。好喝的，乾淨利落。

2006 Vosne-Romanee 1er Aux Reignots, Domaine du Comte Liger-Belair

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense noses of rose jam, red plum, red berry jam, smoke, clove, earth, vanilla and cinnamon type spices. Medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with smooth tannin. On palates it has quite intense flavours of rose jam, red plum jam, red berry, mushroom and licorice. Fairly long length with rose finish. (92)


Tasted on 18 October 2019

仍然是一貫醬果的味道和感覺，這枝酒的香料味很出色，像是一個香料架一樣。酒力強餘韻長，好酒一枝。這個莊的造法雖然大大増加了酒吸引大眾的能力，但減少了酒的田土獨特感覺，真係有點難取捨。

2009 Vosne Romanee 1er Aux Malconsorts, Maison Roche de Bellene

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense noses of black plum, smoke, mint, toasted spice, dried rose and vanilla. It is dry with medium acidity and alcohol, quite full bodied with medium ripe and fine grained tannin. On palate it has medium intensity flavours of black plum, cherry, rose, smoke, earth and licorice. Slightly longer than medium length with black cherry finish. (92) Some depth.

Tasted on 2 August 2019

有一點深度，主要來自發展出來的香料味，幽香感很不錯，酒體醇厚，單寧成熟，中上的酒力和複雜性，餘韻亦算長，佐餐或剩飲都非常好 ，讚。

2005 Vosne Romanee La Colombiere, Domaine du Comte Liger-Belair

Deep ruby coloured with quite intense aromas of rose perfume, black cherry, licorice, red plum, forest floor, vanilla, sawdust. Good depth. It is dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied. Soft and ripe medium tannin as well. On palate it gives quite intense flavours of black cherry, plum, rose jam, licorice, vanilla and touch of menthol. Fairly long length with black plum finish. (93) Good development, complex yet elegant.


Tasted on 2 August 2019


保持著這酒莊一貫的玫瑰香水感，果味及香料味並駕齊驅，發展得很好，複雜而又優雅，香味誘人。酒體柔順，酒味仍維持著其複雜性，餘韻亦長，好好飲，這表現應可繼續維持一段長時間。