2017 Chambolle Musigny Les Charmes 1er Cru, Domaine Gerard Mugneret

Deep intensity ruby colour with quite intense noses of rose, dried strawberries, candied redcurrant, cabbage and licorice, it is dry with medium acidity, alcohol and bodied. The tannin is soft at medium level, surprisingly ripe. On palate it gives over medium intensity flavours of red plum, strawberry, rose pedal, licorice and touch of forest floor. Longer than medium length with red plum finish. (91) Good intensity and nose, some typicity as well.

 

Tasted on 4 October 2024

酒的力度算強勁，香氣亦很好，只是以這條村來說是重了一點。酒的口味反而更符合這條村的感覺，但強度不及香氣，餘韻亦合格以上，難得的是這支酒的丹寧出奇的成熟柔順，不像2017年的酒，整體來說是一支好喝的酒品

1995 Carruades de Lafite

A deep intensity purple coloured dry red wine with quite intense aromas of black plum, menthol, violet, vanilla and touch of mineral and earth. It has medium acidity and alcohol, full bodied with medium ripe and fine grained tannin. On palate it gives quite intense aromas of black cherry, violet, and vanilla. Medium length with black cherry finish. (90) Good intensity but straight

 

Tasted on 4 October 2024

強度戰勝一切的一支酒。接近30年的陳年，仍有着這樣的強度是十分難得的。酒有着標誌性的波爾多左岸紅酒感覺，但是除此之外在沒有什麼令人覺得驚喜的地方，酒味在口中的複雜性簡單了不少，餘韻亦比想像中短，幾好喝。但這酒在口中的複雜性真的令我覺得簡單了⋯⋯

1995 Ch. Pouget

This wine still has purple colour. On nose it has over medium intensity aromas of violet, mint, blueberry, cedar and touch of bell pepper. Medium acidity and alcohol, medium bodied with medium ripe but bit coarse tannin. On palate it has medium intensity flavours of red plum violet, licorice and touch of bell pepper type vegetal note. Medium length with plummy finish. (90) Good development and mature. Drink now. Good nose too.

 

Tasted on 4 October 2024

 

與其話發展成熟，不如說剛過高峰開始有走下坡跡象比較恰切一啲。酒的香氣發展很好，而且亦算有一定強度，當然亦有一定好的複雜性。酒味及餘韻在口中已經下跌了不少，但仍有一定的果味及發展味道，整體融合在一起，是一支老酒的表現，不錯，但不要再陳年了

2002 Ch. d'Yquem

Medium lemon gold in colour with quite intense noses of honey, lemon, peach, dried apricot, grass, stone and touch of mineral notes. It is sweet and full bodied with barely medium acidity. The flavour intensity is quite intense with flavours of bitter lemon, honey, dried apricot, grass and wet stone. Fairly long length with lemon and honey finish. (93) Good integration and classic character, need better acidity

 

Tasted on 6 September 2024

醇厚，真的很厚，口感很重的。有着標準的蘇岱酒感覺，成熟好味，只是酸度略嫌有點點不足，酒的力量很強，由香氣到酒味都一樣，而且很一致，餘韻亦很長，好喝的